A Local Guide to 25+ Popular Restaurants in Orange County NY
A Local Guide to 25+ Popular Restaurants
in Orange County NY
When it comes to the restaurants in Orange County NY, we are fortunate to have so many that are considered the ‘best’. Although many people come to Orange County, NY in order to see the sights, the restaurant scene is no laughing matter.
From fine dining, international restaurants, to hole-in-the-wall spots, you can find it all here.
One of my quests on Hudson Valley Explored is to share these great restaurants and help you plan your next meal out. To help with that, this restaurant guide was born!
This article contains an affiliate link or two. I make a small commission for purchases made through links at no extra cost to you. Read my disclosure for more info.
Why are Restaurants in Orange County NY so Special?
For those not familiar with the area, Orange County NY sits between Rockland County and Ulster County on the left side of the Hudson River.
Reason #1: Orange County is conveniently located just north of Rockland County and is easy to get to.
Reason #2: The area along the Hudson River is a magical place to have dinner, especially during sunset. These are probably the most popular restaurants in Orange County NY because of the views.
About this Guide
Please keep in mind that this list is continually updated as more restaurants are added in the county. If your favorite is not featured here, please reach out to me and let me know.
This restaurant database is organized by restaurant type. Within each category, restaurants are organized by online ratings and personal preference. Nest to each name will include the town the restaurant is found and a short description.
Orange County NY Restaurant Map
Looking for a restaurants in Orange County NY by location? Check the interactive map that shows each restaurant I’ve featured to date. So whether you’re looking for restaurants in Orange county NY in Newburgh, Middletown, Goshen or more, you can find all of them here!
Popular Restaurants in Orange County NY
BBQ
– Billy Joe’s Ribworks, Newburgh: This casual BBQ restaurant located on the Newburgh Waterfront is a great place to grab a bite and take in the views. Billy Joe’s is very popular not only for the food, but also for their theme nights.
– Brother’s BBQ, New Windsor: Brother’s BBQ is a local favorite and it’s easy to see why. With appetizers like Southern Fried Pickles, Sausage Cheese Plate and Beaufort Shrimp; Sandwiches, Burgers, and ‘From the Pit’ Specialties, this is one of the best restaurants in Orange County NY.
Fine Dining
– Blu Pointe, Newburgh: Blu Pointe on the Newburgh Waterfront offers a modern upscale dining experience with amazing views of the Hudson River. This is one of the most popular brunch restaurants in Orange County NY.
Seafood
– Captain Jake’s, Newburgh: Another great Newburgh Waterfront Restaurant, Captain Jake’s goal is to provide a taste of New England to their clientele.
International
– Casa Mia Latin Kitchen, Middletown: Latin/Spanish food offered in their restaurant or as take out. Their Family Value Dinner is a popular choice for many. Diners also enjoy their brunch selections.
– Citrus, New Windsor: This casual dining restaurant offers a dual menu of Indian and Thai cuisine. In addition to their all day menu and wonderful service, they offer a Sunday Brunch fit for a king.
– Cosimo’s Restaurants, Various Locations: Known for their brick oven pizzas, pastas and other familiar Italian comfort foods, you will never be disappointed with a visit to any of the Cosimo’s restaurants.
– Orange Hill Restaurant, Newburgh: They have transformed the space of an old diner into a multipurpose space that offers areas for dining, a coffee bar, a bar and a lounge area. Showcasing their love of food, their menu is both thoughtful and eclectic.
– Wildfire Grill, Montgomery: This homey restaurant offers an eclectic, international menu with a wine bar. The atmosphere is casual and the ingedients are fresh and local.
Modern American
– City Winery Hudson Valley, Montgomery: This winery is a great place to celebrate a special occasion, see an event or just have dinner. They also offer a dine during a show option. Check their website for a look at their menu and events calendar.
– Craft 47, Goshen: This great cozy place offers American small plates, wine and craft beer. Their extensive menu offers plenty to eat and drink, even for the pickiest of eaters.
– Delancey’s, Goshen: This casual dining restaurant offers American dishes including seafood dishes. Their sports bar is a popular place to hang out and grab some pub grub.
– Lakeview House, Newburgh: Set along Orange Lake, this casual dining restaurant offers amazing views of the lake and a great lunch and dinner menu. They also a popular location to host an event.
– Liberty Street Bistro, Newburgh: his fantastic restaurant located on Liberty Street is across the street from Washington’s Headquarters State Historic Site. Their New American tasting menu is inspired by French cooking techniques in a bistro setting.
– North Plank Road Tavern, Newburgh: With garden and patio seating during the warmer months, this New American restaurant is found in a 19th century tavern, complete with a Mahogany bar. They use locally sourced ingredients to produce the finest meals for their guests.
– Oak and Reed, Middletown: Oak and Reed this great restaurant offers American cuisine that is both rustic and chic. Their menu changes seasonally, so make sure to check out their website before heading over.
– Pamela’s on the Hudson, Newburgh: This relaxed restaurant offers American grub, cocktails and live music with splendid views of the Hudson River and the Newburgh-Beacon Bridge. This is one of the popular restaurants in Orange County NY to host an event.
– Tapped, Middletown: This fun gastropub showcases a variety of craft beers, as well as, delicious homemade food. They serve lunch and dinner
Pizza
– Amore’s Pizzeria & Restaurant, Goshen: Family owned and operated since 2009, this popular place offers delicious pizza, salads, wraps, cold heroes, hot heroes, pasta and house specialties.
– Cascarino’s, Montgomery: Winner of Battle of the Best Pizza 2021, this great pizza shop has an extensive selection of regular pizza, gourmet pizza, brick oven pizza, in addition to, appetizers, soups, salads, rolls, wraps, burgers, hot/cold heroes, focaccia heroes, pasta dinners, entree dishes and baked pasta. .
– Marina Restaurant & Pizza, Harriman: Whether your dining in or taking out, Marina Restaurant & Pizza is the place to go! They pride themselves in their authentic cooking and extensive menu.
– Pizza Shop by Cosimo’s, Newburgh: This popular pizza place is not just about the pizza, other familiar dishes are made a little differently, with a new twist. The freshest ingredients are used in all the dishes and it’s no wonder it’s one of the more popular restaurants in Orange County NY.
– Pecorino’s Pizza, Middletown: Proudly serving authentic pizza, they also offer salads, burgers, pasta and dinner specialties, including seafood.
– Pellegrino & Sons Pizzeria, Middletown: This highly rated pizzeria serves up authentic Italian dishes, including pizza, pasta, calzones & more. They use only the finest ingredients including 100% all natural mozzarella.
Fast Casual/Take Out
– Bubbakoo’s Burritos, New Windsor: This great chain has been around since 2008 and offers the freshest Mexican food. What makes this chain different is that they cook their hibachi-style meets fresh and offer burritos, tacos, quesadillas, taco salad and their famous Chiwawa.
More Restaurants in Orange County NY that may interest you:
Popular Brunch Spots throughout the Hudson Valley for you to enjoy!
The Dining Guide to eating on the Newburgh Waterfront
Until the Next Adventure…
Find discounted meals & discounted activities from
my friends at Local Flavor & Groupon!
Check out My Etsy Shop
where you will find deals on Tees, Totes & More.
PRO TIP:
By using a planner, like this one that I created, you can jot down all the events you want to attend & keep track of a year’s worth of outings.
